Don’t Talk About Us, Talk to Us!
By Simphiwe Rens
They may play an important role in many households but domestic workers feel underappreciated and unhappy. They are calling on the government to heed their call for better working conditions and urge employers and the Labour Department to: “Start talking to us instead of talking about us.”
Nomfundo Ngubane, Miseka Mhlanga and Millicent Mothubisi, who all work as domestic workers in a Johannesburg suburb claim there is a lot that still needs to be done in order to deal with the challenges faced by domestic workers across the country, including improving working conditions.
Mhlanga, who has been working as a domestic for over 30 years, says: “The working conditions are tough. The government keeps on promising us that they’ll sort out our grievances but we still find ourselves working under difficult conditions.”
“But when it comes time for voting, you’ll hear them promising us everything just to get our votes. For many years, they’ve been promising door-to-door campaigns where they’ll come and listen to our complaints and concerns but that hasn’t happened yet.”
Ngubane says working conditions in this line of work differ for each person. “Sometimes it is tough and sometimes it is easy. In some cases you would find that a worker does not even have a tea break and they have to work long hours,” she claims.
Muzi Mkhwanazi, UIF spokesperson at the Department of Labour, says it is challenging to assess the working conditions of domestic workers. “Suffice to say, domestic work needs to be professionalised and treated just like all workers (sic) in the country,” he says. “For instance, issues such as employment contracts - some domestic workers have contracts of employment while others do not.”
This is an issue for Mothubisi, who does not receive a monthly payslip and claims she is given her wages in her hand. “It’s a problem. I can’t even open accounts at stores because they all want a payslip."
According to the International Labour Organization’s website, South Africa ratified Convention 189; a treaty aimed at improving labour standards for domestic workers in June last year.The website states that the convention is due to come into force in the country this month. This, according to the South African Domestic Service and Allied Workers Union (SADSAWU), is a key driving force behind the fight by domestic workers to be regarded as “equally important” as other workers in the country. Former domestic worker and Western Cape Provincial Organiser for the union, Sindi Ningiza - claims that domestic workers can anticipate positive developments following the ratification of the convention. Ningiza emphasises however that unions still have a critical role to play in further improving their working conditions. “Some workers are still scared to join unions. This is why it is so important that we reach as many domestic workers as possible so that we get an opportunity to explain to them the importance of joining a union, as well as explaining to them their rights.”
While Ngubane and other workers are aware of unions such as SADSAWU they are apprehensive about joining these affiliations. “I know of instances where people have joined and later lost their jobs but then the unions did not help in getting their jobs back,” Ngubane says. “When reporting to the union about having lost their job, a domestic worker would find the employer hires a lawyer to fight the union and this ends up working against the employee because the union may not have enough resources to hire good lawyers that can fight the issue the same way as the employer can.”
These fears, Ningiza warns, prevent many domestic workers from benefiting from the services being offered to them. “I was also a domestic worker before, and I didn’t even know that I could sit down and share my views and feelings with the employer. I think that is what gives many of the domestic workers the idea that the employers are far more powerful than they are and not even a union could assist in handling their grievances.”
The department of labour has held imbizos in order to address some of these issues including the most recent which took place in April at Mdantsane’s NU 10 Stadium in the Eastern Cape. Although some domestic workers are unaware of these imbizos they still believe that this sort of engagement with the government is important in addressing their challenges. “That’s exactly what we want because here we don’t have a say. We’re unable to approach the employer with certain claims, unless we want trouble,” says Mothubisi.
According to Mkhwanazi, apart from informing domestic workers about their rights, the department uses the imbizos to communicate improvements that are to be made to UIF benefits for domestic workers. “The UIF Amendment Bill proposes an increase in the payment of ordinary unemployment insurance from the current eight months to a year. The Minister (at the imbizos) was also informing (domestic workers) about the training interventions funded by UIF such as the Training Lay-Off Scheme and the fact that it also covers domestic workers,” he says.
Currently, the minimum salary for a domestic worker in South Africa stands between R1146.50 and R1877.70, depending on the areas in which these workers are based; as has been determined by the labour department.
“What can one do with R1200 nowadays? Even the groceries at home are really expensive and that’s not enough. Some of us come from places far away and we have to pay for bus fees, train fees which can even come up to R1000 for going and returning, leaving one with nothing,” says Mhlanga. “R1200 is an insult, really. They’re looking down on us.”
SADSAWU claim that while these rates have improved, especially when compared to pre-1994 salary rates, more can be done. As a result the union is currently in negotiations to increase the minimum wage to at least R2 500 by next year. “(In the past) people got paid about R500 on a monthly basis. You’d find that a woman or man with many children to take care of had to pay for things like school fees, as well as buy groceries and even get transport money out of that to travel to work. This forced a lot of workers to run to loan sharks for financial assistance,” Ningiza explains. However she further emphasises that these rates are just the proposed minimum wage and do not necessarily mean that employers must not pay more than the suggested amount.
When it comes to the job Mhlanga says there are certain things to be appreciative of although the same cannot be said for all domestic workers. “You know, I can’t speak for other people...For instance, for some workers, when they’re sick they are immediately taken to a doctor for medical attention. But we can’t say it’s for everyone because it’s not all domestic workers that get treated in such a manner by their employers – it’s just the luck of a certain few.”
Ngubane’s message to employers is to treat domestic workers with respect. “Speak to us in an appropriate and civil manner. Certain employers tend to have an abusive approach to their domestic workers.”
Ningiza is of the view that domestic workers should be treated like the “queens” they are, and that their value to the country’s economy is key “Imagine if domestic workers can come together and say ‘we’re not going to work’; that would be a disaster.”
*The true identities of all domestic workers interviewed for this article have been altered as requested.
Read the online version of the article here.